The Battle That Forged Modern Baseball: The Federal League Challenge and Its Legacy

The Battle that Forged Modern Baseball: The Federal League Challenge and Its Legacy. . . tell[s] an inherently complicated story in a direct and understandable manner without dumbing it down. . . . This is a work of serious historical scholarship[.] . . . The case presented is highly persuasive that the Federal League challenge, though largely forgotten, was indeed not only a lively chapter in baseball’s history, but one with deep and lasting importance. For the serious student of the development of the organizational framework of baseball as a business, Levitt’s work should be required reading. ― NINE: A Journal of Baseball History & Culture

Dan Levitt has produced a well-researched, well-written account of the machinations of both the Federal League and Organized Baseball as they challenged each other to compete in the same venue. This is not dry, legal stuff but an entertaining and informative recreation of the rough and tumble times of the American game. ― The Past In Review

Anyone who wants to advance beyond the stage of fandom to understand what it takes to establish and run professional baseball would do well to read Mr. Levitt’s fascinating book. ― New York Journal of Books

Author Daniel R. Levitt, in his new book The Battle That Forged Modern Baseball, offers up the most authoritative account yet of the short-lived league. ― The Capital Times

In this compelling narrative, Levitt uncovers the economic and legal battles between Organized Baseball and its last rival, the Federal League of 1913-15. Anyone seeking to understand how Major League Baseball (or the other U.S. sports leagues) came to be structured as the closed monopolies that they are today will benefit from reading Levitt’s excellent book. — Andrew Zimbalist, Robert A. Woods Professor of Economics, Smith College

Daniel L. Levitt’s book on the Federal League is the best work on the subject up to now. Thoroughly researched and well-written, it is particularly impressive in its detailed narrative and analysis of the corporate, financial, and legal aspects of the Federal League’s potent challenge to the two established major leagues―a challenge that, while ultimately unsuccessful, eventuated in the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark exemption of Organized Baseball from the federal antitrust laws. — Charles C. Alexander, Ohio University

If we recall the Federal League today it is for its last gasp: the Supreme Court decision of 1922 that provided Major League Baseball with an antitrust exemption that has endured to the present day. But the story of how it began, briefly flourished, frayed, and collapsed, is a fascinating and instructive tale on many fronts. No one has ever told it more compellingly than Dan Levitt; I cannot recommend his book highly enough. — John Thorn, Official Historian of Major League Baseball

Major league baseball owners love competition when it’s restricted to the baseball field, but when a new major league, the Federal League, declared itself a rival of the American and National Leagues in 1913, they fought hard to suppress it, resulting in the 1922 Supreme Court decision that gave the AL and NL their antitrust exemption and monopoly. Daniel R. Levitt’s The Battle That Forged Modern Baseball is one of the most important historical baseball works so far this century and is a fitting tribute to the 3-year-old league that came so close to beating the barons of baseball at their own game. Despite the defection of big league stars such as Mordecai “Three Finger” Brown and Joe Tinker of “Tinkers to Evers to Chance” fame, the combination of unexpectedly high expenses and relentless legal battles finally wore down the Federals. The real winner of the battle between the AL, NL and the FL was Judge Kennesaw Landis, whose decision in the upstart league’s antitrust suit was instrumental in the older circuits’ victory. In the wake of the Black Sox scandal and other controversies, Levitt writes, in the late 1920s the owners made him baseball’s first commissioner. Ultimately fans were the losers: The two surviving major leagues chose not to expand until 1961. ― Dallasnews.Com