Harm`s Way – Tragic Responsibility and the Novel Form Reprint Edition

Sandra Macpherson’s groundbreaking study of the rise of the novel connects its form to developments in liability law across the seventeenth to nineteenth centuries. In particular, Macpherson argues for a connection to legal principles of strict liability that hold persons accountable for harms inflicted upon others in the absence of intention, consent, direct action, or foreknowledge. In convincing polemical readings of Defoe, Richardson, and Fielding, she shows that these laws share with the novel the view that the state of a person’s mind is irrelevant to the question of her responsibility for her actions. Macpherson urges readers to rethink the ancient consensus that the novel differs from tragedy in its elevation of character over plot. She concludes that the realist novel is ultimately a tragic form, committed to holding persons accountable for accidents of fate.

Macpherson’s original insights continue to have a broad and lasting impact on the study of the novel.

Original, intelligent, fluent readings . . . Highly recommended.–Choice

A wholly original approach to the relation between law and literature, [Harm’s Way] will change the way we think about and teach some of these canonical works of fiction.–Times Literary Supplement

Macpherson bears down intensely on several hard-won and difficult abstractions, including cause, intention, and meaning. To the degree to which we are accustomed to thinking through our most important literary-theoretical categories via a history of the novel, Harm’s Way is a must read.–Studies in English Literature

Macpherson presents a feminist argument of profound integrity and conviction. Harm’s Way compels us to appreciate form not as an aesthetic or structural category but as a guarantor of justice, a way of attributing responsibility that, by divesting liability of mitigating intention, preserves the ‘purely material’ facticity of women’s harm.–Modern Philology

This is a most thoughtful and thought-provoking book. It puts most other attempts to rewrite Rise of the Novel to shame.–Scriblerian

It is at once disturbing, exhilarating, and challenging. Where it succeeds, it dazzles, and where it falls short, it still demands, and deserves, our careful attention.–AMS Press

A thoughtful, innovative, and important study of eighteenth-century fiction.–Review of English Studies

–Jonathan Lamb, Vanderbilt University “Review of English Studies”

Sandra Macpherson’s groundbreaking study of the rise of the novel connects its form to developments in liability law across the seventeenth to nineteenth centuries. In particular, Macpherson argues for a connection to legal principles of strict liability that hold persons accountable for harms inflicted upon others in the absence of intention, consent, direct action, or foreknowledge. In convincing polemical readings of Defoe, Richardson, and Fielding, she shows that these laws share with the novel the view that the state of a person’s mind is irrelevant to the question of her responsibility for her actions. Macpherson urges readers to rethink the ancient consensus that the novel differs from tragedy in its elevation of character over plot. She concludes that the realist novel is ultimately a tragic form, committed to holding persons accountable for accidents of fate.

Macpherson’s original insights continue to have a broad and lasting impact on the study of the novel.

“Original, intelligent, fluent readings . . . Highly recommended.”–Choice

“A wholly original approach to the relation between law and literature, [Harm’s Way] will change the way we think about and teach some of these canonical works of fiction.”–Times Literary Supplement

“Macpherson bears down intensely on several hard-won and difficult abstractions, including cause, intention, and meaning. To the degree to which we are accustomed to thinking through our most important literary-theoretical categories via a history of the novel, Harm’s Way is a must read.”–Studies in English Literature

“Macpherson presents a feminist argument of profound integrity and conviction. Harm’s Way compels us to appreciate form not as an aesthetic or structural category but as a guarantor of justice, a way of attributing responsibility that, by divesting liability of mitigating intention, preserves the ‘purely material’ facticity of women’s harm.”–Modern Philology

“This is a most thoughtful and thought-provoking book. It puts most other attempts to rewrite Rise of the Novel to shame.”–Scriblerian

“It is at once disturbing, exhilarating, and challenging. Where it succeeds, it dazzles, and where it falls short, it still demands, and deserves, our careful attention.”–AMS Press

“A thoughtful, innovative, and important study of eighteenth-century fiction.”–Review of English Studies

Sandra Macpherson is an associate professor of English at The Ohio State University.